Below you can view the high-end and luxury homes in Hartsel. These listings include all Hartsel CO homes over $500,000 for sale. Most of these estates tend to have high-end finishes, gourmet kitchens, and tons of square feet of living space. Call the Gold Compass Real Estate office at 970-658-8181 to schedule a showing of these luxury Hartsel homes. Want more home search options? Use our Advanced Search Tool.
Active, 79 Quail Court in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $1.1m, ,
New12d ago
36
$1.1m
$424
Active
79 Quail Court
Hartsel, CO 80449
1
Beds
,
1
Baths
,
2,592
Sqft
square feet,
Buffalo Gulch Ranch – 160 Acres Near Hartsel, Colorado - Discover Buffalo Gulch Ranch, a 160-acre South Park property offering off-grid living, valuable water rights, hunting, and exceptional improvements. The ranch includes approximately 500 acres of BLM and 300 acres of private grazing leases, expanding livestock and recreational opportunities. The custom barndominium features 2, 592 square feet of heated space. The upper 1, 296 square feet offers open-concept living, kitchen, bedroom, full bath, vaulted ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, barnwood flooring, and 360-degree views. The bathroom features a two-person soaking tub and five-foot shower. Four-zone hydronic heat is fueled by propane or a Pioneer Princess wood cookstove. A 12' x 36' deck overlooks a rifle range with 100-, 200-, 300-, and 400-yard targets. The 1, 296-square-foot lower level features 12-foot ceilings, two bi-fold barn doors, workbenches, storage lofts, insulation, drywall, electricity, water, and hydronic heat. It offers workshop space or potential additional living space, subject to approvals. An adjoining 36' x 12' greenhouse includes watering lines, gas, automated ventilation, growing shelves, and garden beds. A 36' x 40' concrete shop pad is ready for construction. Off-grid power includes solar, wind, and a Generac propane generator. A separate 20' x 16' guest cabin features a covered porch, loft, and barnwood flooring. Two deeded springs with absolute water rights feed Buffalo Gulch Reservoir, with decreed uses including irrigation, livestock, wildlife, piscatorial use, and fire protection. The reservoir retained water during the 2026 drought. A 130-foot well has a recorded pumping rate of 12 GPM. Located in GMU 58, the ranch may qualify for CPW landowner preference applications for deer, elk, and pronghorn, subject to eligibility. Nearby Spinney Mountain Reservoir, Eleven Mile Reservoir, and the Dream Stream offer excellent fishing, boating, and camping.
Active, 59 Whip Way in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $549,000, ,
For Sale
50
$549,000
$305
Active
59 Whip Way
Hartsel, CO 80449
3
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
1,800
Sqft
square feet,
Picture sunrise pouring through tall windows and evenings by a crackling wood stove as snow falls over the Colorado landscape. This newly built, move-in ready ranch home on 2 partially wooded acres delivers true mountain living with quality to match. Built with Insulated Concrete Forms (ICF) and a metal roof, it’s efficient and made to last. The single-level, split-bedroom design means no stairs, with a central family room separating the primary suite from two spacious additional bedrooms. Vaulted tongue-and-groove pine ceilings and an open floor plan make all 1, 800 square feet feel bright and spacious, with Luxury Vinyl flooring throughout and no carpet. The hand-built kitchen is a showpiece: solid beetle kill pine cabinetry, acacia hardwood counters, and a large island with pull-out storage. Large living room windows bring in natural light, passive solar heat, and sweeping views, while the wood-burning stove on its rock hearth will keep things cozy on the snowiest day. Set on a quiet cul-de-sac with a natural canopy of trees for privacy, the property includes a well that allows horses and county-maintained roads for year-round access. The Ranch of the Rockies HOA, only $245/year, offers a stocked private fishing lake, horse boarding pastures and a horse arena, gated RV storage with water fill and dump station, trash service, a pavilion, a communty fire pit, fenced dog run, a full-time ranch manager, and two National Forest access points. Nearby you’ll find Gold Medal Waters, abundant wildlife, and endless fishing, hunting, hiking, and off-roading. Located close to Buena Vista, the Collegiate Peaks, and the Arkansas River, just over an hour to Breckenridge, with short drives to Colorado Springs and Denver. Seclusion and accessibility in the heart of everything Colorado offers. Schedule your showing today!
Active, 121 CO RD 53 in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $699,000, ,
Reduced28d ago
38
$699,000
$310
Active
121 CO RD 53
Hartsel, CO 80449
4
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
2,258
Sqft
square feet,
*$46, 000 PRICE REDUCTION!* Newly constructed in 2025, this custom earth-sheltered style home sits on 3 acres. Thoughtfully designed to take advantage of Colorado’s abundant natural sunlight for passive solar heating, the home also features milled beams and woodwork throughout that add warmth and character. The floor plan includes 4 bedrooms offering flexibility for guests, working from home, or additional living space. A wood-burning stove keeps things cozy, while the interior flower bed is a unique feature that brings a little of the outdoors inside. The home is equipped with a multi-stage water filtration system designed to treat the well water, including iron and sediment filtration, reverse osmosis, mineral treatment, and a 200-gallon storage reservoir. Additional features include a metal roof and a walipini-style earth-sheltered greenhouse for gardening at elevation. Enjoy the privacy and space of 3 acres while still being about 20 minutes from Fairplay and 35 minutes from Buena Vista. The location offers easy access to everything the Colorado mountains have to offer, including hiking, fishing, rafting, camping, biking, and miles of surrounding mountains, rivers, and public lands to explore.
Active, 1807 Windmill Drive in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $500,000, ,
For Sale
40
$500,000
$370
Active
1807 Windmill Drive
Hartsel, CO 80449
2
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
1,352
Sqft
square feet,
Enjoy the peace and beauty of Colorado's high country with this 1, 352 sq ft home on 2.5 acres in the Ranch of the Rockies subdivision.. Relax and take in the views from the deck and gazebo, perfect for enjoying fresh air and beautiful surroundings. The home includes a wood-burning stove for cozy warmth and rustic mountain charm. Wood flooring, and a kitchen island allows for great entertainment. A loft offers space for guests, an office or sitting area as well. Featuring an even more flexible space for guests, a studio, workshop or hobby area is a dry cabin, electric included. With plenty of outdoor space, this property offers the opportunity to enjoy the mountain lifestyle while creating your own Colorado retreat.
Active, 559 Bellows Road in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $737,000, ,
For Sale
50
$737,000
$231
Active
559 Bellows Road
Hartsel, CO 80449
4
Beds
,
3
Baths
,
3,196
Sqft
square feet,
Lovingly hand-built by its original owners and offered fully furnished, this remarkable 4-bedroom, 3-bath custom home is your opportunity to own 8 private acres (see legal descriptions in Private Remarks) in the highly sought-after Ranch of the Rockies. Surrounded by towering pines, beautiful aspens, natural rock outcroppings, and peaceful mountain views, the property offers exceptional privacy while embracing everything that makes Colorado mountain living unforgettable.
Inside, soaring tongue-and-groove vaulted ceilings, handcrafted log railings, and a stunning floor-to-ceiling river rock fireplace create an atmosphere that's both grand and welcoming. Expansive windows fill the home with natural light while perfectly framing the surrounding forest. The open kitchen, dining, and living spaces flow effortlessly onto the oversized composite deck—an ideal setting for morning coffee, wildlife watching, or evenings beneath Colorado's star-filled skies.
The walk-out lower level provides additional living space complete with a cozy wood stove, while the spacious loft overlooks the great room below. Every room reflects the care and craftsmanship that only a custom-built home can offer.
Included with the sale are two adjoining parcels, creating an exceptional 8-acre retreat with room to explore, protect your privacy, or simply enjoy the serenity of your own mountain forest.
Located in Ranch of the Rockies, owners enjoy year-round county-maintained roads, HORSE BOARDING (for a small fee), central trash service, a full-service RV dump and fill station, community mailboxes, and easy access to endless outdoor recreation. Explore nearby National Forest, fish the Gold Medal waters of the Dream Stream, spend the day on Antero, Spinney, or Eleven Mile Reservoirs, or ski Breckenridge before returning home to your own peaceful mountain sanctuary. Ranch of the Rockies is known for its large homesites, abundant wildlife, and access to Colorado's best outdoor adventures.