Homes from $300,000 to $500,000 For Sale in Hartsel CO
View all Hartsel CO Homes from $300,000 to $500,000 For Sale. These average priced homes are great middle of the market options. Some have been completely updated, while others need some TLC modernize them. To schedule a showing of these average Hartsel homes, call our office at 970-658-8181. Want more home search options? Use our Advanced Search Tool.
Active, 65 Bandana Road in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $450,000, ,
Reduced19d ago
37
$450,000
$147
Active
65 Bandana Road
Hartsel, CO 80449
4
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
3,066
Sqft
square feet,
Colorado Mountain Living with Panoramic Collegiate Peaks Views & Private Hot Tub! Positioned on private acreage near Trout Creek Pass in Ranch of the Rockies, 65 Bandana Road delivers an authentic high-country retreat located just 25 minutes from Buena Vista and under an hour to Breckenridge.
This distinctive multi-level mountain residence features upper gabled dormers, rustic wood exterior accents, and an architectural window array designed to frame sweeping views of the snow-capped Collegiate Peaks and Buffalo Peaks. Bright living and dining spaces are oriented to capture natural alpine light, while outdoor living shines with a spacious elevated walkout deck featuring custom western railings alongside a ground-level patio with a private outdoor hot tub (conveniently powered by a standard household circuit) positioned for dark-sky stargazing. Below, a built-in double garage and an expansive, level gravel drive provide abundant space for vehicles, mountain gear, and trailer or RV parking.
Full infrastructure is established, highlighted by an adjudicated domestic water well drilled to 220 feet with a strong tested yield of 9 GPM and a private septic system. Enjoy direct subdivision access into the Pike-San Isabel National Forest for hiking, equestrian trails, and GMU 49/50 hunting, alongside a private stocked trout reservoir and close proximity to Gold Medal waters at Antero Reservoir and Spinney Mountain. With county-maintained roads providing reliable year-round access, this home serves as an exceptional four-season recreation basecamp or peaceful mountain residence.
Active, 14012 S Chickasaw Road in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $449,900, ,
For Sale
50
$449,900
$323
Active
14012 S Chickasaw Road
Hartsel, CO 80449
3
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
1,392
Sqft
square feet,
Welcome to wide-open Colorado living in this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offering 1, 392 square feet on 3.25 acres in Hartsel Ranch. Located just a few miles from Hwy 9, this property offers the peaceful South Park setting while remaining convenient to Hartsel and surrounding mountain communities. Inside, thoughtful updates blend with Colorado character. Warm wood ceilings and walls create an inviting mountain feel, while the remodeled kitchen features updated cabinetry, appliances, workspace and an island perfect for gathering. Large windows bring in natural light and showcase the surrounding landscape. Both bathrooms have been refreshed with modern finishes, and three bedrooms offer flexibility for guests or a home office. Additional features include luxury vinyl flooring, a tankless water heater, water filtration/softening system and grid-connected solar panels. An attached garage and unfinished/workshop space provide room for vehicles, tools and gear. Outside, enjoy 3.25 acres, panoramic mountain and valley views, incredible sunsets and room to breathe. Relax on the covered porch and take in the scenery, with additional outdoor structures for storage, gardening or hobbies. The property is also near the site of the proposed Wild Horse Reservoir. Outdoor recreation surrounds Hartsel, including Spinney Mountain Reservoir, Eleven Mile State Park, the South Platte River and Dream Stream, offering fishing, boating, hiking and wildlife viewing. Known as the Heart of Colorado, Hartsel offers fuel, restaurants, a general store, post office, library and local businesses. Fairplay and Buena Vista provide additional shopping and services. Approximate distances are 18 miles to Fairplay, 29 miles to Buena Vista, 41 miles to Breckenridge, 65 miles to Colorado Springs and 104 miles to Denver. Move-in ready, remodeled and situated on acreage with solar and convenient highway access, this is a wonderful opportunity to own a piece of the Colorado high country.
Active, 386 Angus Circle in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $435,000, ,
For Sale
29
$435,000
$366
Active
386 Angus Circle
Hartsel, CO 80449
3
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
1,187
Sqft
square feet,
Welcome to this very well maintained 1, 187 sq ft home on 8 private acres in Ranch of the Rockies. With 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, the home offers comfortable living and a spacious kitchen designed for everyday ease and entertaining. The freshly painted exterior and durable metal roof reflect careful upkeep and reduced maintenance, while the storage shed (with electric) adds practical space for tools, equipment, or hobbies. The property backs directly to a 13, 000-acre ranch, delivering rare open views, quiet surroundings, and a true sense of space. Whether you want room for animals, outdoor recreation, or simply more privacy than a typical neighborhood lot, this acreage provides it. Ranch of the Rockies offers a mountain-ranch setting with the appeal of larger parcels and nearby open land. Move-in ready and thoughtfully cared for, this home combines manageable size with exceptional outdoor opportunity. *The information contained herein should be verified after buyer contracts to buy the property
Residential
MLS# 3471619Coldwell Banker Collegiate Peaks Realty
Active, 2400 Fourmile Creek Road in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $449,900, ,
For Sale
50
$449,900
$171
Active
2400 Fourmile Creek Road
Hartsel, CO 80449
2
Beds
,
1
Baths
,
2,630
Sqft
square feet,
Set on 36 acres in the Colorado high country, this distinctive off-grid Earthship-style home offers privacy, self-sufficiency, year-round water, and the infrastructure for a true mountain homestead. Located in the Thousand Peaks subdivision between Hartsel and Fairplay, the property combines sustainable design, expansive views, agricultural zoning, multiple outbuildings, and approximately 600 feet of year-round Fourmile Creek. Designed for passive solar living, the home features tire-bale construction, south-facing windows, stone floors and walls that absorb and radiate warmth, and a wood-burning stove in the main living area. Aspen tongue-and-groove ceilings, natural stone finishes, and an open floor plan create a warm, rustic interior. The spacious kitchen offers abundant cabinetry and a large island and flows into the dining area and indoor growing space. A 100-square-foot planter allows for year-round gardening. Generously sized bedrooms, a 12x15 loft, root cellar, utility space, and storage add flexibility. The property includes a private well feeding a 600-gallon indoor cistern and an upgraded solar system with solar arrays, a wind turbine, 16 batteries, two new charge controllers, a new inverter, additional solar panels, and a new generator. Welded steel structures include a garage, chicken coop, sheds, and livestock shelters, with fencing in place. Agricultural zoning supports animals, gardening, ranch use, or a self-sufficient homestead. Fourmile Creek adds a peaceful natural feature to the acreage, which also offers mountain and valley views, room to roam, and exceptional privacy. A professional survey with markers every 100 feet supports future planning. Conveniently located near Hartsel, Fairplay, Buena Vista, and Breckenridge, this Central Colorado property offers access to abundant outdoor recreation while maintaining the seclusion of rural mountain living. Ideal as a full-time residence, high-country retreat, working homestead, or off-grid getaway.
Active, 1807 Windmill Drive in Hartsel, CO 80449, priced at $500,000, ,
For Sale
40
$500,000
$370
Active
1807 Windmill Drive
Hartsel, CO 80449
2
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
1,352
Sqft
square feet,
Enjoy the peace and beauty of Colorado's high country with this 1, 352 sq ft home on 2.5 acres in the Ranch of the Rockies subdivision.. Relax and take in the views from the deck and gazebo, perfect for enjoying fresh air and beautiful surroundings. The home includes a wood-burning stove for cozy warmth and rustic mountain charm. Wood flooring, and a kitchen island allows for great entertainment. A loft offers space for guests, an office or sitting area as well. Featuring an even more flexible space for guests, a studio, workshop or hobby area is a dry cabin, electric included. With plenty of outdoor space, this property offers the opportunity to enjoy the mountain lifestyle while creating your own Colorado retreat.