Colorado Real Estate
Fort-Collins-Banner

Homes For Sale in Horsetooth Lake Estates

Start of list of properties

Under Contract Listings in Horsetooth Lake Estates

Start of list of properties

Recently Sold Homes in Horsetooth Lake Estates

Start of list of properties

$800,000
$286
Sold
4905 Hilltop Dr
Fort Collins, CO 80526
3
Beds
,
3
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Experience Colorado living at its finest in this stunning all-brick ranch with a walk-out basement, nestled in the highly sought-after Horsetooth Lake Estates. Perfectly situated on two spacious lots totaling over an acre, this rare property offers breathtaking, unobstructed views and a peaceful setting that is hard to find. From the moment you step inside, you will appreciate the open and inviting floor plan designed to bring the outdoors in. Massive windows fill the home with natural light while framing the stunning views from nearly every angle. The main level features a comfortable primary suite and a private office, creating an ideal layout for both everyday living and functionality. The walk-out basement offers two additional bedrooms and plenty of space for guests, hobbies, or relaxing gatherings. Spend cozy winter evenings by the wood-burning fireplace, then enjoy the changing seasons from the expansive Trex deck-perfect for morning coffee, quiet sunsets, or simply taking in the beauty and serenity that surrounds you. This property does offer a fenced yard for your 4-legged friends. With timeless all-brick construction, incredible views, and room to breathe, this home offers the warmth, comfort, and Colorado lifestyle you have been dreaming of.
Residential
MLS# 1060380 Coldwell Banker Realty-NOCO
$690,000
$295
Sold
5216 Arrowhead Ln
Fort Collins, CO 80526
3
Beds
,
3
Baths
,
0.48
Acres
,
Wake up to the sun rising over Horsetooth Reservoir and wind down with city lights shimmering below. This foothills retreat offers the best of Colorado living, just minutes from town. Thoughtfully updated and beautifully maintained, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home with a dedicated office blends contemporary rustic style with high-quality finishes throughout. Built with steel framing, the home offers exceptional durability.Inside, the open-concept layout is designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen anchors the space with granite countertops, a large center island, and modern appliances, all just five years old. Newly refinished hardwood floors and abundant natural light create a warm, inviting atmosphere.The main-level primary suite is a true sanctuary, featuring a walk-in closet, a beautifully appointed five-piece bathroom, and sliding doors that open toward iconic Horsetooth Rock views. The walkout basement includes two additional bedrooms and a dedicated office, providing flexibility for guests, remote work, hobbies, or additional living space. A large multi-purpose room with direct outdoor access creates the perfect space for a media room, gym, or play area.Step outside to a spacious Trex deck, perfect for morning coffee or evening gatherings, surrounded by native grasses, thoughtfully designed landscaping, irrigated window boxes, and buried French drains for effective water management. Unwind in the two-person outdoor soaking hot tub imported from Estonia after a day of hiking, biking, or boating nearby.Additional upgrades provide both comfort and peace of mind, including a newer furnace, A/C, tankless water heater, and three exterior doors with transferable lifetime warranties. The exposed aggregate circular driveway (2022) adds both beauty and function.With sweeping views, intentional upgrades, and a setting that feels like a true escape, this home captures the essence of Colorado foothills living.
Residential
MLS# 1061489 Colorado Realty 4 Less, LLC
$745,000
$255
Sold
5001 Overhill Dr
Fort Collins, CO 80526
5
Beds
,
3
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Views. Space. Colorado living at its finest. Perched above Horsetooth Reservoir, this spectacular 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom home with a dedicated office and flex/rec room delivers breathtaking views of the reservoir, marina, and Horsetooth Mountain Park from nearly every angle. Fresh paint, new flooring, and beetle kill wood trim give the interior a move-in-ready feel with authentic Colorado character. The updated kitchen features cherry cabinets, Silestone countertops, and new stainless steel appliances. Main-level hickory hardwood floors flow through the open-concept living area, anchored by a wood-burning stove with a moss rock hearth. Sliding glass doors open to the wrap-around deck - perfect for soaking in the views and wildlife. Upstairs, three bedrooms include the stunning primary suite with a picture window framing the reservoir, walk-in closet, spa-like bathroom, and private office with patio access. Main-level laundry adds convenience. The walkout basement offers exceptional multigenerational potential - two bedrooms with their own walkout sliding glass doors, a bonus rec room or gym, a second washer/dryer hookup, and an easy entrance. Additional highlights: new roof (2022), two A/C units, low-e windows, radon mitigation, and a freshly resurfaced and regraded driveway. Outside, a 20, 000 SF lot features a bonus flat space - rare for this hillside setting - plus natural landscaping featuring mature trees, a flagstone patio and walkways.Trail runners, hikers, and mountain bikers - world-class recreation starts at your door and just a short and scenic 15 minute drive into town.
Residential
MLS# 1061483 Group Mulberry
$289,000
$180
Sold
4708 Foothills Dr
Fort Collins, CO 80526
3
Beds
,
1
Baths
,
0.46
Acres
,
**HOME IS BEING SOLD IN CURRENT CONDITION**(Manufactured Home) Opportunity, flexibility, and charm all come together with this cottage-style modular home situated on a spacious half-acre lot with no HOA. Connected to city water and electric, the property offers the convenience buyers want while still providing room to spread out and make it your own. The home is being sold as-is because the sellers have decided to move forward rather than undertake additional updates before listing. Instead of paying for renovations chosen by someone else, buyers have the opportunity to finish improvements in a way that matches their own style and budget. The property has already had meaningful work completed over time and is priced to reflect remaining updates and modernization. Whether you're looking for an affordable primary residence, investment opportunity, weekend retreat, or property with long-term upside, this home offers a rare chance to own usable land, city utilities, and no HOA restrictions in a setting full of potential and character. Tank-Less Water Heater. Room Sizes Coming.
Residential
MLS# 1059347 Assist 2 Sell - Ortiz Realty
$653,076
$409
Sold
5416 Continental Dr
Fort Collins, CO 80526
3
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Experience the perfect blend of mountain living and everyday convenience in this beautifully updated home just minutes from Fort Collins. Ideally situated near Horsetooth Mountain Open Space, this property offers unmatched access to hiking, biking, and wildlife, while Horsetooth Reservoir is just a quick five-minute drive away for boating, paddleboarding, and lakeside relaxation. Set on a spacious .4-acre lot, this 2, 240 square foot home features 3 bedrooms (3rd bedroom non-conforming) and 2 bathrooms, thoughtfully designed to capture the beauty of its natural surroundings. Inside, you'll find fresh interior paint and tastefully updated bathrooms, creating a clean and modern feel throughout. The cozy wood-burning fireplace serves as the heart of the home, perfect for relaxing after a day of outdoor adventure. Step outside onto two brand-new decks, ideal for entertaining or simply soaking in the sweeping views and peaceful mountain setting. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee or watching local wildlife pass through, this property offers a true Colorado lifestyle experience. Energy efficiency meets functionality with fully owned, free-and-clear solar panels, helping reduce utility costs while embracing sustainable living. The oversized garage with 220-amp service provides ample space for vehicles, tools, or a workshop setup, while two outdoor sheds offer additional storage for all your gear. This home is a rare opportunity to enjoy mountain tranquility without sacrificing proximity to town. With easy access to Fort Collins, outdoor recreation at your doorstep, and thoughtful updates throughout, this property truly captures the essence of Colorado living.
Residential
MLS# 1055539 RE/MAX Alliance-Wellington

Schedule to See Homes Today

Call Us 970-658-8181

6 + 2 =

Horsetooth Lake Estates Subdivision

Horsetooth Lake Estates consists of 186 homes which are located in the south western region of Fort Collins. This subdivision is ideally surrounded by several parks in the neighborhood and is located at the intersection of W Country Road 38E and Overhill Drive. The housing is mostly ranch and 2 story with a few bi-level and raised ranch with 1500-2000 above grade square feet. Majority of the Horsetooth Lake Estates homes for sale were built between 1977 and 2008 with impressive manicured huge lots of third of an acre to half an acre. The floor plans average 2000-2500 finished square feet and have a 2 car attached garage. Some of the homes in this subdivision have a basement. Mcgraw Elementary, Webber Middle and Rocky Mountain High School are the schools located nearby and children from this area attend them. The community is managed by Horsetooth Lake Estates. Several restaurants and shopping spots are located nearby to this location. Lory State Park, beautiful park with so much activities such as hiking, biking, water activities and has fabulous views is located just a short drive from Horsetooth Lake Estates.

Selling a Home in Horsetooth Lake Estates

See what your home is worth With an Instant Home Valuation Online. Want advice on selling your house? We provide a free staging consultation, pre-listing prep plan, and a Horsetooth Lake Estates real estate market analysis. Call us at 970-658-8181 to learn more.

Local Schools

School District:

  • Poudre

Elementary School:

  • Mcgraw Elementary School

Middle School:

  • Webber Middle School

Senior High School:

  • Rocky Mountain High School

New to the Area? Call our Horsetooth Lake Estates real estate agent at 970-658-8181 to schedule your tour of Homes in Fort Collins CO.

We Love to Hear from You!

Send Your Questions or Call 970-658-8181.

7 + 1 =

Advanced Fort Collins Home Search

Communication is the foundation to building trust, so we make it a priority to be available to our clients through phone, text, Facebook messaging, email and in-person meetings. Our laid back approach to home buying is centered around outstanding personal service and gives you the time you need to find the perfect home.

We will help educate you about your options so that you can make well-informed decisions throughout the home buying and selling process. Our friendly and responsive team will make you glad you chose Gold Compass Real Estate to help reach your real estate goals.

Meet Our Team

Gold-Compass-Real-Estate-Logo

 

Austin Hurt Profile Picture

Gold Compass Real Estate

Owner & Employing Broker

Office: 303-325-5690

Text: 720-441-3050