Colorado Real Estate
Loveland-Banner

Homes For Sale in Horseshoe Lake

Start of list of properties

Under Contract Listings in Horseshoe Lake

Start of list of properties

Recently Sold Homes in Horseshoe Lake

Start of list of properties

$900,000
$208
Sold
3840 Flagler Ave
Loveland, CO 80538
4
Beds
,
5
Baths
,
3
Garage
,
Rustic Colorado Charm Meets Modern Comfort in The Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake! Beautifully appointed 4 bedroom, 5 bath home nestled in the desirable Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake subdivision, offering warm wood finishes, spacious living areas, and an inviting Colorado-inspired design. Set among mature trees and beautifully maintained landscaping, this exceptional home combines privacy, comfort, and the sought-after lifestyle of this special community. The main level features welcoming gathering spaces perfect for everyday living and entertaining, while the upper level offers three bedrooms and three full baths, creating comfort and privacy. The fully finished log-themed basement provides an exceptional additional living space - complete with a fourth bedroom, full bath, and generous family room-ideal for entertaining, a guest retreat, or multi-generational living. Step outside and embrace Colorado living on the covered back patio, featuring a built-in grill, mounted TV, mature trees, and professionally landscaped surroundings. Whether enjoying a quiet evening at home or hosting friends and family, this outdoor space is designed for year-round enjoyment. A spacious three-car garage provides ample room for vehicles, storage, and all your Colorado gear. For added peace of mind, the home has been pre-inspected, giving prospective buyers the opportunity to purchase with added confidence and a clear understanding of the home's condition. Located in the sought-after Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake, this move-in-ready property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy both an exceptional home and an exceptional community.
Residential
MLS# 1068050 Group Harmony
$679,000
$243
Sold
3799 Flagler Ave
Loveland, CO 80538
2
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Located on the peninsula of Horseshoe Lake, this home sits within a coveted private community - water on three sides, mountain views to the west, and 91 acres of protected conservation land that ensures the surroundings stay untouched.Inside, the home has been completely reimagined - this open layout is finished with materials and craftsmanship typically reserved for custom builds. Refinished solid oak hardwood floors anchor the main living spaces beneath vaulted ceilings with wood beams, where a fireplace with hand-painted tile surround and abundant natural light. This premium corner lot backs to protected and well-maintained community green belt. The outdoor area features Colorado Buff boulders, pavers, split-stone planting beds, and a fountain beneath a flowering pear tree. The kitchen is the centerpiece - a Taj Mahal quartzite island with waterfall edges and hidden walnut cabinetry, Thomasville storage, an integrated refrigerator, and Monogram Minimalist appliances. A Texas limestone focal wall frames the walnut hood and open shelving, giving the space warmth and architectural weight in equal measure.The primary suite carries the same level of finish: cedar beam vaulted ceilings, mountain views, and a floor-to-ceiling marble ensuite with Schluter heated floors, a curbless waterfall shower with Grohe fixtures, a floating European toilet, and a hand-made walnut vanity with linear mirrors. The second bath is wrapped in Carrara marble with all-new fixtures. A redesigned laundry room features Samsung appliances, built-ins, and a retractable folding table.The investment goes well beyond aesthetics. A state-of-the-art water heater, new furnace, and professionally installed upgraded insulation mean 3799 Flagler is as efficient and worry-free as it is beautiful. Unfinished basement provides room for expansion or storage. Don't miss this fully transformed home, finished to a standard you won't find at this price point, in a location that simply cannot be replicated.
Residential
MLS# 1062773 8z Real Estate
$575,000
$265
Sold
1634 Animas Pl
Loveland, CO 80538
2
Beds
,
2
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Low maintenance living awaits in this meticulously cared for patio home, perfectly situated in the desirable Horseshoe Lake subdivision, where lakes, trails, dining, and shopping are all nearby for your convenience and outdoor adventures! Step inside to an open concept design flooded with natural light, large windows, hardwood floors, and vaulted ceilings. The heart of the home is the pristine kitchen that flows seamlessly into a cozy living room with a warm fireplace. The updated kitchen boasts an abundance of cabinet and counter space, newer appliances, soft-close cabinetry, and a gas stovetop. The spacious island is just gorgeous with colors that complement the white cabinets perfectly. With over 2, 100 finished square feet of main level living, everything you need is thoughtfully designed on one floor. Your spacious primary suite serves as a true retreat, complete with large windows, a fireplace, a walk-in closet with floor to ceiling built-ins, and a 5 piece ensuite bath. The main level continues with a second bedroom, a separate dining area, a welcoming front sitting room, and a versatile flex room perfect for an office or a third bedroom. With updated touches in the bathrooms as well, this home is entirely move-in ready. The seamless layout extends outdoors, where the home backs to a greenbelt, allowing you to soak in the Colorado sky from the comfort of your private deck under a custom pergola. Designed for ultimate peace of mind, the property features new water heaters, and a newer AC, saving you from surprise upkeep costs. A 2 car garage protects your vehicles from the elements, while a massive unfinished basement with egress windows stands ready for your creative touch. Best of all, there is no Metro Tax and the HOA handles snow removal and lawn care, giving you a true lock-and-leave property. Schedule your showing today!
Residential
MLS# 1063132 Group Centerra
$630,000
$253
Sold
3731 Osier Pl
Loveland, CO 80538
3
Beds
,
3
Baths
,
2
Garage
,
Welcome to 3731 Osier Place, a beautifully maintained ranch style home nestled in the highly desirable Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake, offering Front Range and lake views in a peaceful, picturesque setting. Built in 2005 by Don Burns Construction Co., this quality crafted residence features nearly 2, 500 finished square feet, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, convenient main level living, and a partially finished basement. The inviting main floor includes a spacious living room with a cozy corner gas fireplace, a formal dining area, and an eat-in kitchen designed for everyday comfort and entertaining. The primary suite offers beautiful views, a luxurious five-piece bath, and generous space to unwind. Two additional bedrooms and a full bathroom complete the main level. Downstairs, the partially finished basement provides a large family room and recreation area, a three-quarter bathroom, and abundant storage space. Additional highlights include newer Marvin windows, ceiling fans in all bedrooms, exterior outlets for holiday lighting, and an oversized finished two-car garage featuring a workbench and hot and cold water service. Outside, enjoy mature landscaping, a covered back patio, and the tranquil surroundings that make this home truly special. Exceptional views, thoughtful touches, and a sought-after location combine to create a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the Colorado lifestyle.
Residential
MLS# 1062238 Group Centerra
$950,000
$226
Sold
2152 Seven Lakes Dr
Loveland, CO 80538
5
Beds
,
5
Baths
,
3
Garage
,
Enjoy Lakeside Living with Spectacular Mountain views. Stunning two-story home with elegant finishes. Marvelous kitchen, large island, numerous cabinets along with a walk-in pantry. Open floor plan where sleek built-ins surround the gas fireplace, and a dramatic wall of windows that frame the beauty of Horseshoe Lake. Main Floor Primary with 5-piece bath, newer California closet, with a scenic view of the lake. Walkout basement features a spacious family room with a cozy fireplace and wet bar, a flexible room serving as a game room, office, or guest suite, a separate card-playing area, plus additional gathering space. Just outside the patio doors you will find a hot tub for year-round enjoyment. Upstairs offers three spacious bedrooms - one with an en-suite bath and two with shared hall bath - plus a bright, open-concept loft overlooking the lake. Outdoor living is effortless with a heated, covered deck where you can relax and watch geese, eagles, and black swans soar over the lake. The HOA maintains all landscaping and snow removal, so you can simply enjoy your surroundings. Homes in The Enclave at Horseshoe Lake are rarely available - don't miss your chance to call this one yours
Residential
MLS# 1045603 Group Harmony

Schedule to See Homes Today

Call Us 970-658-8181

10 + 13 =

What is Your Loveland Home Worth?

Get your answer in 15 seconds!

Horseshoe Lake Subdivision

Horseshoe Lake is situated at the intersection of E County Road 24E and Seven Lakes Drive. The homes are located in the Peninsula of Horseshoe Lake and consist of 180 homes. This subdivision is situated in the north eastern region of Loveland. You will find mostly 2 story with a few ranch, tri-level and four-level with 2000-2700 above grade square feet. Majority of the homes were built between 2000 and 2009 with 3000-4000 finished square feet. The homes landscape on impressive lots of 6000 square feet to fifth of an acre and have a 2-3 car attached. Kids in the area will attend Blair (mary) Elementary, Ball (conrad) Middle and Mountain View High School. The community is managed by Peninsula At Horseshoe Lake which covers amenities such as park area, common area maintenance, snow removal and lawn care. This subdivision is ideally surrounded by several parks in the neighborhood and the views of the parks from the home are a treat to the eyes. Boyd Lake State Park, a well maintained park with nice paved trails for biking and has beautiful camping spots in located close by Horseshoe Lake.

Selling a Home in Horseshoe Lake

See what your home is worth With an Instant Home Valuation Online. Want advice on selling your house? We provide a free staging consultation, pre-listing prep plan, and a Horseshoe Lake real estate market analysis. Call us at 970-658-8181 to learn more.

Local Schools

School District:

Elementary School:

  • Blair Elementary School

Middle School:

  • Ball Middle School

Senior High School:

  • Mountain View High School

New to the Area? Call our Horseshoe Lake real estate agent at 970-658-8181 to schedule your tour of Homes in Loveland CO.

We Love to Hear from You!

Send Your Questions or Call 970-658-8181.

13 + 4 =

Advanced Loveland Home Search

Communication is the foundation to building trust, so we make it a priority to be available to our clients through phone, text, Facebook messaging, email and in-person meetings. Our laid back approach to home buying is centered around outstanding personal service and gives you the time you need to find the perfect home.

We will help educate you about your options so that you can make well-informed decisions throughout the home buying and selling process. Our friendly and responsive team will make you glad you chose Gold Compass Real Estate to help reach your real estate goals.

Meet Our Team

Gold-Compass-Real-Estate-Logo

 

Austin Hurt Profile Picture

Gold Compass Real Estate

Owner & Employing Broker

Office: 303-325-5690

Text: 720-441-3050